(gold) Jay Arnette
1960 basketball
(gold) Rex Cawley (a.k.a. Jay)
1964 400 m hurdles
(silver) Jay Silvester
1972 discus throw
(gold) Mike Burton (a.k.a. Jay)
1968; 1972 swimming - 400 m freestyle; swimming - 1500 m freestyle
(gold/silver) Jay Barrs
1988 archery - individual; archery - team
(bronze) A. J. Hinch (a.k.a. Jay)
1996 baseball
(gold) Jay Bouwmeester
2014 ice hockey