Straight outta the 60s! Very sitcom wholesome with that vague sense of underlying uneasiness.
Alpha males playing house.
Craig is sort of handsome in a... craggy way. He sounds born with salt-and-pepper hair. It sounds like an old movie star.
Scott is delightfully "dumb jock with a heart of gold". If parents used these today I would definitely think they are into rockabilly or something.