New Post
Search
Help[Opinions] Re: Is it wrong to give your baby a tribal name if you're not from that tribe?
in reply to a message by Apozanolotl
No, it's not wrong. People can name their own baby anything that is meaningful to them. Even if she's white. It's not anybody else's business, not even a sister's. I think it's about as sensical for a husband to feel like a wife is appropriating his culture, in naming his own child, as it would be for him to feel like it was a snub of his culture if she chose a name from her own heritage. Like he's just looking for reasons to get offended.
- mirfak
- mirfak
This message was edited 10/14/2024, 11:44 AM
Replies
Well he is not sensical J he just worried that the culture would go to the wrong hands.I not K's sister.I married to J and so is K.J not just looking for a reason to be offended.
100% agree
100% disagree
You asked for opinions and you got them 🤷♀️
ok
Sorry but I agree with Mirfak. I have Cornish ancestry going back to at least 1622 but my husband D has no Cornish ancestry at all. Does that mean we shouldn’t pick a Cornish name because any child of ours would only have Cornish ancestry from 1 parent. As it stands we have decided on a Cornish name for a hypothetical girl. I love the name that we decided on and the meaning of the name means something to both of us.
Right? As an American myself I can only fathom how complicated this would be if American couples with unending combinations of ethnicities used the same thought process 😅🤣🤣🤣 no one would have a name in the end, lol
mmmmm ok