Hello, my virtual naming spouse! lol
"I like names with a bit of history, and often classic names that either aren't very popular now. I do like some names that are always popular." --right on! I'm the same way. I tend to like old, obscure names, but I love the established classics. I am a devout Catholic, though, so an added thing is that saint names are important for me.
My top 5-ish:
Cyrus,
Daniel,
Corin,
Peter,
AlbanEliza,
Anne,
Alda,
Eve,
Sabine