Honestly, I'd wait and see her little face, hear her little voice, and then decide. Both names are nice, but have a different "feel" and one might seem to fit better than the other.
I generally prefer
Elisabeth.
Isabella seems a tad princessy or "eurochic" to me, in the same vein as
Luca and
Gianna. I also don't find the nickname
Bella attractive.
Or maybe it's just because
Elizabeth just seems more comfy to me, as an English speaker with no living European relatives.
I think
Isabella goes better with the other names you've listed, if that matters (except
Grace and maybe
Claire).
This message was edited 4/11/2008, 9:57 AM