Yeah, I don't know where half the nicknames come from for some names.
Margie I sort of understand because if you saw that name, (not knowing it was associated with
Margaret), that's how it would be pronounced (at least to me). But
Peggy? Where did that come from. That's actually my mom's name and people ask her if it's short for
Margaret, but it's not in her case.
Margaret Alice sounds nice. I don't know how much I like
Alice, but I like
Alison. Maybe
Margaret Alison? Thanks for your suggestions! :)