If you detach the religious associations, I think this is a strong and powerful name. There are many religious Christian names too (Mary, Abraham, Christian, etc.), so other cultures shouldn't be judged with a double standard.
Islaam was the name of an undeveloped conjoined twin with craniopagus parasiticus born in 2005. She had to be separated from her twin to give her twin a chance to live. Poor kid. Rest in Peace.
I stumbled across this name while I was looking up the name Isla. Didn't know this was a name... Would probably work in Muslim countries but outside of them, nope.
― Anonymous User 5/15/2020
3
Islam Karimov, former president/prime minister of Uzbekistan, had this name.