I like
Elinor, but in this family,
Eleanora is my favorite.
I would DEFINITELY spell it
Eleanor, not
Elinor. I grew up on an
Elinor Rd. Every time I gave out my address I'd have to spell it out for the person. This wasn't such an issue, but if it were my first name (rather than my street) I think it would have been really annoying, especially when people continued to get it wrong.
I knew an
Eleanor growing up, but no
Elinor (apart from my street).
Ellie is my favorite nickname for any of these
Elinor/
Eleanor/
Eleanora names.