Not sure if you play this game here, but I saw it on another site and decided to give it a try
Heaven, Hell, Purgatory
First player, place two names in Heaven and two in Hell, then post the new list.
Subsequent players - copy previous poster’s list
Move your two favorite names from Purgatory to Heaven
Move your two least favorites from Purgatory to Hell
Then move your least favorite name from Heaven back to Purgatory, and your favorite from Hell back to Purgatory as well
Feel free to give reasons for WHY you chose the names you did
Post the new list
Once all names are out of Purgatory, delete one name from Heaven (the one you like least), and one from Hell (the one you like most) until there is only one name on each list.
Purgatory: Adrian, Alexander, Brian, Byron, Charles, David, Erik, Frank, Gabriel, Gregory, Harrison, Henry, Ian, Jacob, Jared, Joseph, Kevin, Kyle, Luke, Matthew, Michael, Nathan, Nicholas, Oliver, Paul, Quinn, Ralph, Ryan, Sean, Stephen, Thomas, Timothy, Ulysses, Victor, Walter, Wayne, Xavier, York, Zachary, Zane