These were the most popular names in the nineteenth century:
Girls-
MaryAnnaElizabethEmmaAliceEdithFlorenceMayHelenKatherine
Boys-
WilliamJohnCharlesHarryJamesGeorgeFrankRobertJosephThomas
I found these in "Beyond
Jennifer and
Jason,
Madison and
Montana". These names were the most popular for the United States as a whole, but I'm guessing that these names were very popular in the South as well.