View Message

Both are pretty, but there's something about Starla that's weird to me.

Starla is prettier and more unique. Carla is pretty but not as interesting.

Carla, by a wide margin. Starla just seems more "stage-name-y" than anything. I just can't take it all that seriously. Carla is more practical and also has a better sound to it anyway.

I prefer Carla, though I'd prefer other fem forms of Carl, Charles etc. Starla is half-way to Starling, and while they are delightful birds, I wouldn't use their name or a form of it. I prefer Stella to both Starla and Carla.

Both are pretty, but I choose Carla, although I prefer the spelling Karla.

Carla is fine. Starla is kind of cringy.

Carla! Starla kind of makes me want to claw my eyes (ears?) out...

I like them both now, because I can admire their brassy style, though I used to hate Carla. Starla is a bit more eccentric and fun, so I'd probably pick that one.

I'd choose Starla, since I find it so gorgeous and unique. I have never met anyone called Starla in person before. Carla is also a very wonderful-sounding name; I think that it's beautiful. However, Starla would win for me.

Carla is ok, don't like Starla