View Message

Petal or Rainbow
For a daughter. Has to be one or the other.Bonus points for thinking of a middle name. "And by the way, dearie, your punctuation sucks canal water!"
-The Ghost of Vivian Vance
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Rainbow Aurora. :-PIn honor of Holly Madison. It's just too bad the baby's last name won't be Rotella. Rainbow Aurora Rotella is so perfect, especially if my child ends up stuttering.
vote up1
Petal Jane "PJ"Actually Petal is growing on me more and more by the second. I love Gretel so it's an easy sell
vote up1
Petal. Can't really think of a middle name. Rose Petal if she can have her middle name first.
vote up1
Petal. I love it.
vote up1
Rainbow. I just like the sound of it more than I like the sound of Petal. Also it doesn't have the soft, limp feel of Petal.Rainbow Janice. Why the hell not?------------------------------------------------------------------------

This message was edited 1/9/2017, 7:56 AM

vote up1
I can actually see Petal working in the UK. I used to have Rainbow on my guilty pleasure list, because I like the sound of Rain and Bow. I think I'd go for Petal. Petal Henrietta Sally.
vote up1
Rainbow, like the band
vote up1
Petal is unbearably sentimental! Rainbow isn't much better, but Rain definitely trumps Pet as a nn, so Rainbow it is.Rainbow Rose (very William Blake)
Rainbow Melody
Rainbow Griselda
Rainbow Susan
vote up1
Definitely Rainbow because Petal is waaay too precious. I'd call her Rain and try to forget about the 'bow' ending.
vote up1
WellAt first I was all "totally Petal. Petal has a quirky sort of respectability and restraint to it, and puts me in mind of woodland fairytales and animals with good manners. Rainbow is so brash and obvious and tacky, it's a Lisa Frank day-glo disaster". But dwelling on Rainbow's outrageousness actually made me fond of it. It's so unapologetically itself. It's like a punk rock unicorn. There's something about Petal that almost seems embarrassed of itself, like it comes with a built-in apology. I respect Rainbow's preposterousness.Also as a North American, the word "petal" in my accent is not nearly so sweet and pretty as the word itself looks. Saying it out loud: "PED-ull"...it's just not pleasing and brings to mind car parts or animals peeing on rugs. Though I also mispronounce Rainbow regularly - it always comes out like "Raimbow" - it's still nicer than poor flatfooted Petal. IN CONCLUSION Rainbow Amanda
vote up1
There's something about Petal that almost seems embarrassed of itself, like it comes with a built-in apology. I respect Rainbow's preposterousness.This! Thank you.
vote up1
Rainbow. I actually like Rainbow, it's a GP. Petal is way to frail.
vote up1
Just one petal? not a whole flower? I think that's why I don't like the name. Preferred the Whole Rainbow.
vote up1
Petal for sure. I already like Petal a lot. Petal Hannelore
vote up1
Petal for sure. I already like Petal a lot. Petal Hannelore
vote up1
Ok, I have to admit, I actually like these names! Rainbow only for a mn, but Petal I could see as a fn, so I'm going with Petal Jemima or Petal Martha.
vote up1
PetalIt doesn't sound strange on a girl as Rainbow does.
vote up1
PetalI actually don't hate Petal. I call my youngest niece Petal (Gretel) Petal Firefly Moonbeam Saffron Sky
lol.
vote up1
It is a hard choice but I have to go with Rainbow, the nicknames and meaning are better! Though I like Pethalia which is a name I made up for one of my characters!
vote up1
Rainbow.Rainbow Dawn.
vote up1
Petal Anne
Petal Christine
Petal SophiaPetal Anne Nicole
Petal Olivia Hope
Petal Kapri Ivory
vote up1
This is just mean. I'd probably go with Petal, because it's easier to pronounce where I live and most people here wouldn't even know that it's flower related.
vote up1
Rainbow Maeve
vote up1
Petall'm a fan of Petal. Petal Josephine is my go to combo for it.
vote up1
Ha.
I was thinking about saying 'Petal Josephine' as well, but then got lazy and decided not to mention a MN at all. :)
vote up1
Hi !!!Rainbow !!!!
It is a magical name!
I can see it as a full name without problems...Petal has a nice meaning...but a horrible sound imo.Byeeeeeeeeeeee
vote up1
Rainbow
vote up1