I like both pronunciations and I often pronounce
Sophie the French way in the middle spot as well. I was thinking the English pronunciation more-so in this case though, since I think
Loretta's straight-forwardness, as you put it, gives a more informal vintage American feel that I find sort of endearing. But I definitely like both combos, and I think
Gemma Sophia Everild is softer and more elegant in a way. I am also enamored with
Everild, but I worry that the combo is lacking some vitality, whereas
Gemma Loretta Sophie has a vintage spunk. I've also always preferred under-appreciated
Sophie to
Sophia personally. I think I just have to mull this one over though. Both combos have their merits.