I, too, love simple names. But there's simple & elegant vs. simple & corny, admittedly sometimes a thin line. My mother-in-law wanted simple corny names for her kids and named them
Betsy,
Dick &
Sally. None of them have appreciated this.
Sally probably has weathered the choice the best. Not that they'd like something super complicated, just something that doesn't sound so juvenile now that they've all grown up.