Yes, I'm saying it just like
Amy. Although my first instinct is to pronounce it like the French word, and I'd like it that way, too.
Amie Eliza was one I'd thought of but it seemed too youthful. I thought
Olive and
Amie seemed like a good match, too, but somehow they don't fit together quite right for me. I do think
Amie Eleanor (I'd like to remove the -e),
Amie Georgiana,
Nolwenn Amie, and
Tegwen Amie are quite nice.
I think that's my problem with
David, too. It's just everywhere. But for some reason I don't feel the same about
Michael!