View Message

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

Re: Roma?
Roma = GypsyIt's the name of a human ethnic/cultural group, so it seems kinda inappropriate to use it as a personal name.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I also agree with you on this. My great-great-grandfather was Roma. I'm proud to have even a bit of that blood. :-)
vote up1
I agree.And as for the other examples--Cheyenne, Roman, etc--they don't really affect how I hear Roma. Maybe time will change that, but for now I completely agree with you and don't care for it as a given name.
vote up1
People use Cheyenne, Dakota, etc.I'm not in love with Roma, either Cheyenne or Dakota, or the practice itself, but it's widely accepted to name children after Native American tribes. Why not Roma?
vote up1
"widely accepted"lots of people have problems with it. Lots of people on this board.
Plus Gypsies are a pretty widely oppressed minority. It seems really patronizing to use their name as a cutecutenameformylittlegirl~!...I also disagree with Lillian. Frank is more a reference to Francis, which does indicate a nationality but more of a nationality than a tribe. Norman came into popular use as reference to a surname which comes from the tribal name. German did not begin as a tribal name - Germany was named in reference to the Latin given name. Roman grosses me out a lot, but so do Dakota and Cheyenne, so there you go
OT I love your current favorites a lot. I need to start playing with Zimri some more. GREAT Zimri combo.
vote up1
I said widely accepted because those names are relatively common. I am 1/4 Cherokee and not personally a fan of using names of ethnic groups, but there are too many little Dakotas and Cheyennes running around for me to get upset every time someone uses those names. So Roma--especially since it can be interpreted as a reference to the city of Rome (and thus likened to London and Paris more than Cheyenne and Dakota)--doesn't particularly bother me, either.But don't get me started on people who butcher the spellings . Shyanne? That makes me angry.Thank you! It's awesome that you like Zimri. ^_^Edit: Haha, OMG. I had no idea Cherokee was in the database.

This message was edited 6/19/2008, 9:10 AM

vote up1
Also Frank, Roman, German, etceteraI don't see that particular reason as being sufficient to dissuade from use of Roma.
vote up1
DittoI think it would still be ok to use, though. I personally like the name Roman. But Roma seems to bring about the Gypsy concept more because Gypsies are called Roma, not Romans.
vote up1
Agree
vote up1