View Message

Lily
What is your honest opinion on Lily?Any middle name suggestions?Thanks
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I have an inexplicable aversion to all names with the 'lil' sound in them. This includes, but is by no means limited to: Lilian, Lillith, and Lilibet. I have no idea why, but I have the same thing with 'max'.
vote up1
I think it's a really pretty name. It's sweet and feminine, but to me, it also has some spunk. I like the length of it and the sound. The only thing is that it's very popular right now. That doesn't necessarily bother me too much though.
vote up1
I think it's lovely but I prefer it as a nickname for Liliana, Lilia, or Lillian / Lilian.
vote up1
I love Lily. It is one of my favorite names and I may or not use it for my baby girl. I have not decided whether to use it. The combo if I use it will probably be Lily Katherine. Lily Emma, Lily Juliet, Lily Rose, Lily Grace, and Lily Madeline are great too.
vote up1
It's a very pretty name, yet so common!
Flower names can become pretty trendy, so I'd shy away from it for a while. My current favorite flower name is Hyacinth.Anyway, MN suggestions are wide open.Lily Alexandra
Lily Anastasia
Lily Genevieve
Lily Katharine
Lily Miranda
Lily Rebekah
Lily Ursula
Lily Victoria
etc. etc.
vote up1
Ooh, love Lily Victoria! It's so pretty. But then again, I probably only like it because it has Victoria in it, lol.
vote up1
How about Lily Unworldlietta:-P
vote up1
Huh?
vote up1
That was odd....
vote up1
It's not common where I live so I don't have this whole "oh it's so popular and overused"- feeling. It's on my PNL and I like the sound of it. I wouldn't use it though. I had a guinea pig named Lily Fleur :)
vote up1
I love Lily, but prefer it as a nn for Liliana or Lillena.
vote up1
i think it's too common but otherwise would be lovelyalthough i would prefer Lilith for the meaning.
vote up1
Lilly will be my daughter Lillian's NN so I love it. I'll probably call her Lillian most of the time though.
vote up1
At one time, I loved Lily. It's very soft and almost fragile. Lately, it's just so common that it has lost most of its luster for me. The mns I like best with Lily tend to have at least three syllables:Lily Beatrice
Lily Caroline
Lily Catherine
Lily Christina
Lily Corinna
Lily Francesca
Lily Margaret
Lily Miranda
Lily Rebecca
Lily Susanna
Lily Victoria
vote up1
Why not Lucy instead?I think it's flimsy and unrefined-sounding. I really despise the name Lily beyond measure. I hope I do not ever meet anyone with this name because it will surely put my in an awful mood. The myriad of parents using this name should consider the infinitely more attractive Lucy.

This message was edited 3/16/2008, 8:24 AM

vote up1
I know a girl named Lily and she is a doll. The name fits her beautifully...Lucy is cute, too, but Lily is great!
vote up1
Just out of personal curiosity, what does and doesn't make names refined?
vote up1
Well, it's honestly the kinds of parents who utilize this name that give it this feel.
vote up1
LOLIf it's the type of parents, how would suggesting an alternative name to them change anything?Personally, I don't mind that Lily's really popular. It's sweet without being too sweet (I think the L's give it a certain awkwardness), and some names have to be more popular than others. Lily's nice. I am glad I have managed to overcome the "images" associated with names when I am considering whether they are good names or not; it enables me to be happy to meet a Lily, Emily, Emma, Victoria, James, Jacob, or William.
vote up1
I don't mind that it's common. I love the name Emily. It's just that it's so unsubstantial. It's like she's saying. "Hi! My names LILLLLLEEEEEEEEEEEEE. STEP ON ME! :-D"
vote up1
I've seen people from teenage moms to late life moms use this name.
I'm not picking, but just trying to understand.
vote up1
Well to me it's a mixture of poor taste, and a want for your child to always sound like a child without considering her place in the adult world.
vote up1
I disagreeI actually think that Lily can go both ways, and I can see it on women from a tiny child to a woman in her 90's. I think it's sweet, but "sweet" does not mean "unrefined." It's attractive and I know very few Lilys.
vote up1
and I can see it on women from a tiny child to a woman in her 90's.Maybe in the backwoods of West Virginia.
vote up1
Hey, watch it.I'm from West Virginia, buster. We're not all rednecks and hillbilles. They're more toward Southwestern WV. (*cough*Calhoun County*cough*)I've only met two Lilys, FYI. One is 9 and one is 60. I don't like it as a full name, but I think Lilith and Lillian are nice, if not names I would use.ETA: I read your other post. Elizabeth nn Lily is nice as well. :)

This message was edited 3/16/2008, 1:19 PM

vote up1
LOL. Sorry. I am native Marylander. It's just an expression we use. Meant no offence.
vote up1
Yeah, I know. [m]I was born in Maryland and we moved to WV (Eastern Panhandle) when I was four. I live in the more civilized area of the state. The Southwestern part is like a whole different world; it's amazing. They use swinging bridges and they have more unpaved roads than any other place I've seen. It takes forty minutes to get to a store from some places!
vote up1
I wouldn't know what goes on there, I've never been. But I live in Los Angeles and I can definitely see it.
vote up1
Well, I'm from South Dakota and I've known several people named Lily...although one (who was 100 years old thank you) went by Lilly (with 2 L's).
vote up1
So you would prefer Lillian, Lilith or a "fuller" sounding name where Lily would just become the NN?
As a more mature naming choice?

This message was edited 3/16/2008, 8:35 AM

vote up1
Well, I'd prefer Elizabeth nn Lily. I don't think Lillian or Lilith are often shortened.
vote up1
Fair enough, thanks for clarifying your logic.
vote up1
I love Lily, but am sad at the overuse of Lily-type names.
I think Lily Seren is neat, because its a play on one of the types of lily. :)
vote up1
I absolutely love Lily. But I fear that it is becoming way too popular for my taste. That's really unfortunate, because I dislike popular names, but this is one of my favorites. My favorite combo is Lily Kerensa.
vote up1
I like it. It sounds soft and gentle, and I love the flower.How about Lily Cate, Lily Isolde, or Lily Ember?

This message was edited 3/16/2008, 6:54 AM

vote up1