View Message

Lillian or Lily?
Which one is prettier?
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Honestly... Lilliana
vote up1
I prefer Lillian and find it prettier but if she would be nn Lily anyway and you wouldn't use Lillian then I would stick with Lily.
vote up1
I really like bothso my pick is Lillian nn Lily- best of both worlds. Yay.
vote up1
LillianI think Lillian is so beautiful.Lily is pretty, too, but doesn't come close to Lillian, in my opinion.
vote up1
Lilian
vote up1
Lily. I prefer just Lily.
vote up1
They're both beautiful, but I slightly prefer Lily's sound, but I prefer Lillian because it's much less common. ETA: Wow, I didn't realize Lillian was catching up with Lily so quickly on the charts! So I'll vote for Lily. :)

This message was edited 7/30/2007, 7:53 PM

vote up1
Lily!Lillian reminds me of an old lady, sorry
vote up1
I may be alone here, but....Lily.
Sorry, I don't like Lillian. Though I do love Liliana.
vote up1
I agree tooI've never cared for Lillian. I adore Liliana, Lilia, and just plain Lily, though.
vote up1
DittoI prefer Lily / Lilly to Lillian. I really like Lilyana.

This message was edited 7/30/2007, 7:52 PM

vote up1
Yay, I'm not alone
vote up1
I like Lily (Lilly) better.
vote up1
LillianI really dislike Lily, so I would hope you wouldnt shorten Lillian anyway. I would prefer to see Lillian nn Lily instead of just Lily though as Lily is not a full name to me (unless you are a flower).
vote up1
I like Lillian. Its my grandmothers mn. However my cousin has a daughter Amber Lillian, so if i was to use it as an honorary name i would use Lilly as a mn(its just as nice).
vote up1
Lillian
vote up1
Lillian
vote up1
I prefer Lillian if you aren't going to use a nickname, and Lily if Lillian would become Lily anyway.Array
vote up1
DittoI like both of them a lot, and don't mind Lily as an occasional nickname for Lillian. But I don't like the idea of using Lillian if you only like Lily but want a more "formal" name. Lily works fine on its own, in that case.
vote up1
Lillian:)
vote up1
Lillian
vote up1
ditto
vote up1