View Message

[Opinions] Poet?
I was reading an actress named her daughter Poet and calls her Poe for short what do you think of it?
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I'm a poet, but wouldn't name myself or anyone else Poet.
vote up1
Its a GP of mineI think a little girl named Poet would be adorable.
vote up1
I like Poet, but not Poe. If it were up to me, there would be no nicknaming there.
vote up1
I'd never actually use it, but I think it fits the family well.
vote up1
I really like Poe, but although I like the sound, look and meaning of Poet I don't think it's a good name. I think it's too much to lay on a child, it's so much more an image than profession. And the child might be the most unpoetic person ever.
No, if so, only MN.
vote up1
I think it is very pretty and lyrical. A hippie bohemian kind of name. Poe is an ok nickname but takes all the prettiness away.
vote up1
I love both Poet & Poe, though more as guilty pleasures : )I also like Poe on a boy, and yes I am an Edgar Allan Poe fan ; )
vote up1
Poet SiennaHer mother is Soleil Moon Frye - quite the pattern. Honestly: I don't care for it. I think Poe is cute, but I wouldn't use it for a female.
vote up1
DreadfulPoet just doesn't sound like a name. Her daughter is destined to be crap with words.
vote up1
I like it, as a GP with the nn Poe
vote up1
Would consider it as a mn only
vote up1
Poe appeals to me......And on either sex, because I love the singer Poe as well as Edgar Allen. ;) Poet seems too contrivedly fanciful, if you know what I mean. It doesn't do it for me.And the actress you're thinking of is Soleil Moon Frye.Array
vote up1
Makes me think of the teletubbie
vote up1
Ditto! Clearly I'm not very cultured :-)
vote up1
Po v. PoeI know this is really, really silly of me, but the spelling changes the entire feel! I know they still sound the same, but in my mind, when I hear the sound "po" and know it's spelled Poe, it feels right. If I hear it and know that it's spelled Po, it sounds icky and teletubbyish to me. I can't explain it, but my mind automatically fills in the connotations, I think.
vote up1
I agree that the spelling makes a difference. In general it makes a huge difference to me, cos I'm another one of those people that sees words spelt out in their head :-)But because we never studied any Poe at school and I haven't read any since, I just don't have enough associations with him for the 'e' to mean anything yet. (I certainly will read some of his work when I get round to it, because i've heard such good things about it here.)

This message was edited 2/21/2007, 3:02 AM

vote up1
fair enough...It's not silly at all. What you expressed here makes perfect sense. You said it best with Edgar Allan Poe. I like a balanced view so I definitely consider & appreciate your input.:o)
vote up1
I don't like word names, especially of the labeling sorts, so Poet is wholly unappealing to me. Poe, on the other hand, is a total GP for me (what can I say, I love Edgar Allan), but I'd use it for a boy.
vote up1