I'm a bit weird, because I do like many names that others would consider to be cutesy, even though they are full word names such as
Lily or
Posy.
I also like
Holly.
But I hate
Molly and I find
Polly really really cutesy, even though sound-wise it's close to
Holly and I guess not any more cutesy than
Posy?
But the fact that
Posy and
Poppy are word names and
Molly and
Polly are nicknames somehow does make a difference to me.
Now I don't find
Polly too childish to use. I could see it working. But I don't really like it.
And yes, I'd pick
Poppy. I find it cutesy but not as much as
Polly. I also LOVE the flower. One of the most beautiful flowers.
Please rate my list:
https://www.behindthename.com/pnl/6232