View Message

[Opinions] Harlan on a girl?
I was watching a YouTube vlog yesterday in which a woman gave birth to a girl named Harlan. WDYT? It sounds all-male to me but maybe is on its way to becoming unisex /feminine? I’m not really one for surnames as first names as a general rule."We have met the enemy and he is us" Walt Kelly
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Um, I remember liking it in the early 00s, but now it sounds ugly on both genders to me. But it's never sounded exclusively to masculine me because of names like Logan (I've only known femme ones), Harper, Harlow, and even Harriet.

This message was edited 7/27/2019, 4:08 PM

vote up1
It is fine for a girl: I do not have a personal gender association with this name.What is it that "sounds all male"?
vote up1
Harlan EllisonAll I can think of.
vote up1
I could see Harland as unisex, but Harlan seems masculine to me.
At least it wasn't Harlyn though... I think Harlan is better than Harlyn, and even a bit better than Harley.
vote up1
Harley feels more feminine than Harlan. Maybe Harlane could work?
vote up1
It doesn't seem very feminine but it fits with the trends for sure. I could see it becoming popular.
vote up1
Nope, don't like it at all on a girl. But I can see it rising for them, with so many surnames being used as unisex names, and with the popularity of Harlow and Harper. But those I can imagine for a girl, Harlan feels completely unfeminine to me.
vote up1
sorry I dont like it for a girl, not too bad for a boy
vote up1
I've never heard of this name, I think it's fine on a girl but I don't like it (Harland or Holland would be better). It sounds too much like harlot, Harley (motorcycles), or harlequin. Not great associations in my book.

This message was edited 7/26/2019, 1:40 PM

vote up1
Harlan screams good ol' country boy to me so it's very difficult to imagine on a girl.
vote up1
Same! Especially since Best in Show is one of my favourite movies.
vote up1
No. I don't even like it on a boy. The "Har" beginning makes it sound…harsh.

This message was edited 7/26/2019, 1:08 PM

vote up1
It looks like it has been picking up for girls since like 2008.https://www.behindthename.com/top/beyond.php?name=HarlanTBH it reminded me of this article I posted on my facebook months ago-- KFC asked parents to name their children born on September 9 'Harland' after the Colonel and one of them won $11,000 (https://people.com/food/kfc-colonel-sanders-name-contest-baby-girl/). Silly.
The Har- sound is ugly to me, so I don't like it.
vote up1
That just shows education needs to be more affordable!
vote up1