I'm the other way. I really enjoy
Betsy, which seems cheerful and friendly, even though the only
Betsy I've known IRL (sister of a friend, full name
Elizabeth) was anything but.
Edith retains a little medieval charm, but not enough. Too breathy. My late MIL was
Edith Elizabeth, but nobody ever used either - she was universally known as Bunty, including by her grandchildren. And the only other
Edith I've ever known was/is
Edith Linda Marie, which sounds OK but none of them seem to go well with the others!