I find
Wilfred to be dorky beyond all comprehension.
I think it would be shortened to
Wil unless you got ahead of it and started calling him
Freddie exclusively. I think there is even a good chance that
Wilf will become
Wil.
I think I like
Freddie the best.
Wilf sounds like a sound a dog makes.
Freddie is cute enough. I can't take
Wilfred as a full name seriously...and there aren't many names that legitimately fall into the category for me.
Wilfred Caspian Stewart Arnold?
Wilfred Oberon Stewart Arnold?
Wilfred Russell Stewart Arnold?
I adore
Theodora and think you guys made a great decision.
Theodora is strong, elegant, and classy.
Wilfred is awkward and comical.
Wilfred would be a good middle name if
Dave loves it so much though. Middle names are where anything goes to me.