View Message

[Opinions] Mabel or Ruth?
Both vintage names making comebacks- or at least getting a bit more recognition than they used to- and both in the, 'names that remind me of hand-sewn quilts and warm oatmeal cookies' category. Which would YOU pick, if you had to choose? "And by the way, dearie, your punctuation sucks canal water!"
-The Ghost of Vivian Vance
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Mabel.
vote up1
RuthMabel sounds 90 years old.
vote up1
MabelRuth is so harsh and cold. I probably have that impression because it also reminds me of 'ruthless'. Mabel is warm but has some backbone to it still. I actually much prefer the nickname Ruthie to the name Ruth itself.
vote up1
Ruthie reminds me too much of roofie the drugs illegally put into someone elses drink.
--------------
vote up1
Mabel, no doubtShe could go by Mae or Mabie. Mabel has a cute sound, anyway. Ruth is just ugly.
vote up1
Ruth, but not really fond of eithernm
vote up1
RuthI don't like Mabel.
vote up1
Ruth, but I like Mabel too.
vote up1
Mabel
vote up1
I've always loved the understated beauty of Ruth, so it would be my personal pick. I also like Mabel very much, and May would make a good nn; I knew a Mabel Leigh Ln at school, a really wonderful girl, but she always went by Leigh which I thought was a pity. Nothing wrong with it, but it's a bit thin compared to the history and pizazz of Mabel.
vote up1
I say Ruth. I'm not too wild about either but Ruth was my grandma's legal name so I can use it to honor her.
vote up1
Ooo, two cuties! i like Mabel for its vintage feel, but I like Ruth because it's my mom's name. Ruth does not have the same vintage feel to me at all.
I really don't know which I would choose. If I had a Mabel, I would call her Mae and if I had a Ruth, I would call her Ruthie. Too cute!
vote up1
Ruth!I love Ruth. It never makes it to my top 10 lists for some reason, but it's a name I could see myself actually using one day. I've honestly never seen it as an old lady name because I've only seen young people named Ruth.Mabel is gross and sticky!
vote up1
Ruth - because it's a lovely Biblical character.
Mabel reminds me of "Mabel at the table" - as a British comedian, Wilfred Pickles, used to introduce his wife in their TV/stage act.
Ruth is also timeless.
vote up1
RuthI like both, but Ruth has Ruthie and the Book of Ruth.
vote up1
MabelRuth is okay as an honoring mn other than that I have issues with it. The biggest issue is it is so hard to pronounce, it is much easier to say Roof so any Ruth I meet usually becomes Roof. Also the only word I can think of that begins with Ruth is Ruthless.Ruth looks nice enough but it sounds much better in my head than when I say it. It sounds so terrible when said out loud.To be fair I have a borderline speech impediment when it comes to th. I can make the th sound but it feels much less natural than f sounds. Ruth is especially hard since it is one syllable and it ends on the th sound, with a name like Anthea or Dorothea or Theodore it is much easier to pronounce.Mabel is okay, I prefer Maple. Maybelle is actually nicer sounding than Mabel but Mabel looks nicer and doesn't seem made up like Maybelle.
--------------

This message was edited 8/10/2016, 5:44 PM

vote up1
Ruth. I've always loved it.:)
vote up1
RuthRuth was on my girl name list.
vote up1
RuthMabel would be pretty to me if prn. May-BEL but at least where I'm from our gets prn. May-BUL.:0)
vote up1
Mabel
vote up1
MabelI really like Mabel, it's vintage, it's charming, it's warm, it makes me think of maple syrup. I hate Ruth, I just see no charm in it all, only ugliness.
vote up1
MabelI like both by about the same amount, I just slightly preferred Mabel this second.
vote up1
RuthThey're both about the same for me but I slightly prefer Ruth.
vote up1
vote up1