Tough callI like both names. Julia is unquestionably prettier, but Ingrid needs to be used more often. I guess I would lean towards Ingrid for that reason alone.
I'm really not a bit keen on Julia, or Julie. The only Jul- name I enjoy is Juliet, but I'd only use it as a nn to fend off Julie.Ingrid is my least-liked -rid name. First Sigrid, then Astrid and only then Ingrid. It isn't bad, but it is dull.