Thanks for the suggestions
Benjamin - way too common for our tastes.
Ben is very boring to me.
Bennett - Actually like this but can't use it because it's just going to get shortened to
Ben :(
Benson/Benton - not as nice as the others.
Benedict/Benedikt -
Love Benedict, however two problems.. 1. He would get called
Ben 2. Our last name is
Arnold!
Brenton - Not a fan
Bryant - same as
BrentonBarrett - It would get shortened to
Barry here! :O
Beckett - I actually really like this, though I worry its too trendy sounding. Its a cute nod to my name!
Branson - not bad..
Bridger - too 'rough' sounding for me
Bryce/Brice - I know too many!
Bastian/Sebastian - too popular
Gerard - nice