It's not 'beautiful' but it's not really far out at all. Seems conventional to me. It's what guys named
Schuyler are called familiarly. And in the real world,
Schuyler is not a girl name. It is masculine.
Sky is usable and I agree, sort of ruggedly handsome, not quite cowboy though. If anyone thinks it's ruined by also being a girl name, I have a big scornful snort for them. It's an edgy girlname *because* it's a boy name in the first place, like
Kyle or
Ryan. (
Skye is different)
My mom watched soaps on tv when I was a kid, and I first heard the name
Sky (male) on a soap opera character in the 1980s. I googled him...
http://www.welovesoaps.net/2012/08/sky-raven-from-edge-of-night.htmlThe Sky/Raven relationship was the only thing I remember ever enjoying about mom's soap operas. Or any soap operas, ever. Not that I've watched many.