Tell me the romantic tragic story!
I could perhaps get into
Horace given time; it's not that bad, though I'd have to get over Slughorn. But I love
Horatio. It is slightly OTT but who cares, it's such a big splendid flourish of a name, waving Hooray (tio) at you in a cheerful manner. There could be something to be said for a calmer middle name, perhaps; but I'd just choose the one with the best story.
I don't know the CSI dude so here are some of the more interesting
Horatio combos from the 1840s birth records:
Horatio Mountain (my fav)
Horatio Folkestone (no idea if that's a family name or if they just had a nice holiday once in Folkestone)
Horatio Colchester (born in Colchester)
Horatio HamletHoratio AugustusHoratio LionelHoratio Regwald
Horatio Francis Henry William ThomasHoratio Bellamy
Horatio Frohawk
Horatio Winckworth
Horatio Olivia Albert - no typos: it's handwritten. There are also two unrelated
Horatio Elizabeths! and a trillion
Horatio Nelsons.