[Opinions] Popularity
The most popular boy and girl name in 2009. Any opinions on naming kids after "famous" people (quotations optional) or, like here, book characters?
Replies
I'd name my baby after a personal hero in some way. But i'm not really a fan of One-person names (names which are so connected to a certain person that people will assume you named the baby after them), especially if you really dislike the famous bearer.
I like the famous people idea, as long as they are famous like Leonardo da Vinci and not like Leonardo da Caprio. I like naming people after book characters if the characters are good namesakes, and I prefer it when they aren't from something dreadfully popular and trendy like Twilight.
Jacob and Isabella are a far cry from something like Bilbo and Cinderella.
Twilight wasn't published until 2005, and Isabella was already #6 at that point and had been rising steadily through the 1990s.
Jacob has been #1 for the past decade, and was #5 for the 1990s.
I personally like a lot of literary names, so I don't care if names come from a book or not. Just the *trend* with Twilight names gets under my skin and I don't have any interest in vampires so the whole attraction to naming a child after a fictitious vampire is lost on me. I don't think that most of these parents are naming their kids after Twilight characters though, seeing as the names were so common *before* the first book was released.
Twilight wasn't published until 2005, and Isabella was already #6 at that point and had been rising steadily through the 1990s.
Jacob has been #1 for the past decade, and was #5 for the 1990s.
I personally like a lot of literary names, so I don't care if names come from a book or not. Just the *trend* with Twilight names gets under my skin and I don't have any interest in vampires so the whole attraction to naming a child after a fictitious vampire is lost on me. I don't think that most of these parents are naming their kids after Twilight characters though, seeing as the names were so common *before* the first book was released.
I didn't mean the names Jacob and Isabella specifically, just the idea of naming kids after a trend. Harry (Potter), Hermione, Storm (x-men) etc.
Also I think there is a difference between literary names and (tween) crazes with people relatively soon forgotten.
Also I think there is a difference between literary names and (tween) crazes with people relatively soon forgotten.
You put your name as Jacob/Isabella so I figured you wanted a response to the specific Twilight names.
My bad, sorry.
I think there's a huge difference between more classical literary names and the new series as well, but I guess one isn't inherently better than the other.
While I like a lot of literary names, I wouldn't say I'm naming my kids *after* a character.
My bad, sorry.
I think there's a huge difference between more classical literary names and the new series as well, but I guess one isn't inherently better than the other.
While I like a lot of literary names, I wouldn't say I'm naming my kids *after* a character.