This is my name, pronounced Alice with a ch. People often mispronounce it but I guess I’m use to it. Known as Chal by those closest to me and I usually only get positive things said about my name.
We named our daughter Chalice. It is a beautiful and rare name that fits her well. It is reminiscent of the cup from which the Lord poured the wine at the Last Supper. Thus, a sanctified vessel of life.
I agree with what mdmaddox said in 2015. I think that this name is very Christian and should be taken at more than face value. The Chalice as a vessel, not necessarily as a modern cup. It's something holy but still accessible. Antique yet eternal. That's why I see merit in the name.
The French translation, "câlice", is used as a sacre (profanity) in Québec. I didn't think this was a great name to begin with, but as a Canadian this basically seals the deal.
There are a lot of words out there that sound pretty, but that doesn't mean they should be used as names. Just because this is so similar to Alice doesn't make it ok to use as a name.