New Post
Search
Help
ArchivesRe: Could you please tell us where you found this data and how it was collected? (nt)
in reply to a message by Cleveland Kent Evans
Hello,
I found it on www.beliebte-vornamen.de
This is what the site says about it:
"Hit lists of the most popular given names…
… for every year from 1890 to 2009
Because there is no official German given name statistics, the team of beliebte-Vornamen.de determines regularly the most frequent baby names. For it more than 100,000 natal announcements from completely Germany were evaluated in 2008.
The most frequent given names of 2008"
May I ask why? Is there a problem that i posted this list on behindthename.com?
http://www.babynames.com/namelist/9622924
Mom to:
Julian Dominic *28.05.2005*
My Angel in Heaven *26.05.2009*
My pets:
Tweety & Lilly (Cats)
Bella (Dog)
Muffin (Rabbit)
I found it on www.beliebte-vornamen.de
This is what the site says about it:
"Hit lists of the most popular given names…
… for every year from 1890 to 2009
Because there is no official German given name statistics, the team of beliebte-Vornamen.de determines regularly the most frequent baby names. For it more than 100,000 natal announcements from completely Germany were evaluated in 2008.
The most frequent given names of 2008"
May I ask why? Is there a problem that i posted this list on behindthename.com?
http://www.babynames.com/namelist/9622924
Mom to:
Julian Dominic *28.05.2005*
My Angel in Heaven *26.05.2009*
My pets:
Tweety & Lilly (Cats)
Bella (Dog)
Muffin (Rabbit)
1
Replies
Thanks to Rene for pointing out the copyright issue.
Many people who regularly participate in the "facts" board on this site are serious about researching various aspects of names in a scientific or at least scholarly way. It is therefore important to be able to give the sources of information that is posted so that the accuracy of the source can be fairly judged.
Many people who regularly participate in the "facts" board on this site are serious about researching various aspects of names in a scientific or at least scholarly way. It is therefore important to be able to give the sources of information that is posted so that the accuracy of the source can be fairly judged.
1
In your post, your quote from the beliebte-vornamen.de website stops exactly before this crucial sentence:
"The hit list of names is subject to copyright."
Unfortunately it seems that Mr. Bielefeld did not translate his copyright conditions to English, but basically they say no copy anywhere without his explicit permission.
Most often it is better anyway to just link to sources, IMHO, whether there are copyright restrictions or not.
"The hit list of names is subject to copyright."
Unfortunately it seems that Mr. Bielefeld did not translate his copyright conditions to English, but basically they say no copy anywhere without his explicit permission.
Most often it is better anyway to just link to sources, IMHO, whether there are copyright restrictions or not.
This message was edited 8/6/2009, 4:58 AM
1