For me, it's not as if I'm intentionally going for weird names. It may be a part of my "gosh darn odd taste" (hee), but I tend to be attracted to names with certain visual and aural characteristics -- and some of those names may be unusual. For example, I usually like names with at least one "hard" sound, and I usually dislike "frilly" names. I like names ending in -ith, -eth, and -is and dislike names ending in -ella, -leigh, and -bel. I like many Welsh and Finnish names because I find the aesthetics of those languages attractive, and I also find Germanic and Scandinavian names interesting. And so on.
I don't really consider popularity and normality when liking a name, though I may dislike a name if it suddenly becomes insanely popular as a result of hype aversion.
If you look some of my names, you'll find both "normal" and "unusual":
Girls:
Adelle, Arsendis,
Bonnie,
Branwen,
Christiana,
Constance,
Dagmar,
Emilia,
Ingrid,
Leah,
Lydia,
Margery,
Rosamund,
Tellervo, Tirion,
Winifred.
Boys:
Alasdair,
Anton,
Bran,
Daniel,
Erik,
Faramund,
Gareth,
Kenta,
Llewellyn,
Lysander,
Owen,
Rhys,
Sheridan,
Taliesin,
Tristan,
Vincent,
William.
I do skew toward the unusual, but this is more of a result of liking certain qualities in names than going for weirdness. I also tend to like a lot of older names that haven't been popular for a long time (like
Margery and
Rhoda).
I also agree with
Norah's statement of self-selection. A lot of the people here are name nerds so there is a higher exposure to unusual, ethnic, and yes, "weird" names as opposed to the average person on the street.
This message was edited 6/17/2011, 8:18 PM