View Message

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

All names come from words
in reply to a message by Aiver
It is not like the names fell down from heaven. People used words as names, just like my name, which means she-wolf.And since "colleen" does not mean "girl" in English, I don't see the problem. Erin is another Irish name, not used in Ireland. Does not mean that it cannot be used outside Ireland."You sought a flower and found a fruit. You sought a spring and found a sea. You sought a woman and found a soul. You are disappointed." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Okay, all I ever said was I dislike the name Colleen because it's just like calling a child "Girl" to me. You're Swedish, right? Would you like the name Flicka for a girl?Image hosted by Photobucket.com

This message was edited 9/6/2005, 8:24 AM

vote up1
So to you its okay to call a child Laddie Lassie Missy Sonny Girl Boy Infant Female Male excetra as long as you dont live in England, or their equivilent in other languages as long as you dont live in the country of originA childs smile is worth more to me than Gold
vote up1
Yes, why not? We would not use these names in Sweden b/c almost everyone knows English. But it also depends on tradition; if a name is used as a name for a long time, who cares about the meaning? I think Bonnie and Darleen are used as names in English-speaking countries.And people use first names which mean "blind", "lame", "ewe", "dog", "small", "bad luck", "misshapen head", "crooked nose" (Cecilia, Claudia, Regina, Rachel, Caleb, Paul, Mallory, Kennedy, Cameron) etc, without caring or knowing about the meaning. So it seems narrow-minded to say that Colleen is not a good name, just b/c it means "girl" in Irish."You sought a flower and found a fruit. You sought a spring and found a sea. You sought a woman and found a soul. You are disappointed." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
vote up1
I never said Colleen was a bad name I just wanted to see how you felt about other forms of address being used as names
You see I think its rather impersonal to call a child by a form of address almost as if they dont deserve to have a name,
I see nothing wrong in a name meaning girl being used if the word it originates from is not in everyday usage or if the name is used in a county where the word isnt in everyday usage.
However Names like Missy and Sonny might be cute on a five year old but they dont age well and seem a bit ridiculous on a fifty year old when used here in EnglandA childs smile is worth more to me than Gold

This message was edited 9/6/2005, 5:46 AM

vote up1
"colleen"I don't know if it's still currently used, but "Colleen" is not only based on a word meaning girl, but "colleen" is sort of slang for "girl." It's a little different than just having a name come from a meaning; it can be used interchangably to this day, feasibly, in this way.
"I like this phrase, 'pleasure calculus.' Is it truly as erotic as advertised?"
http://www.qwantz.com/index.pl?comic=599
vote up1