New Post
Search
Help[Opinions] Re: New PNL
in reply to a message by KK
Happy Birthday!
My thoughts:
Girls -
9/10: Alice
Very nice! My fifth favorite girls' name at the moment. I prefer the Welsh form Alis, though
8/10: Lydia, Marie, Josephine, Caroline
Lydia and Josephine are very pretty! Not currently on my favorites list, but they'll probably get on there someday. Marie is my 14th favorite girls' name right now. I'm fond of Caroline. I think I prefer Coraline, but they're both very nice.
7/10: Julia, Anastasia, Maddalena, Fleur, Ivy
These are all either names that are very pretty but not quite my taste (first 3) or names I used to really like but have lost their appeal (last 2)
6/10: Maria, Charlotte, Clementine, Sophia, Rosalie, Laurel
These are names that aren't my taste, or I've had unfortunate associations with. Sofia would be a 7/10. Rose, my 4th favorite girls' name at the moment, would be a 9/10.
5/10: Helen, Eleni, Emma, Matilda, Isabela
I can see the appeal of these names, but they either just don't feel quite right (first two) or I don't like (last three).
4/10: Melanie, Giulia, Madeline
Names I'm not a fan of.
2/10: Eleanor.
I just can't stand Eleanor, unfortunately.
Boys -
9/10: Antonio
Somehow this name isn't in my favorite boys' fifty, but I love it.
8/10: Owen, Jonathan, Thomas
These are in my favorite boys' fiftyish. All good associations.
7/10: Joseph, Nathan, Elliot, Andrew, Theodore, George
First four were old favorites that have lost some of their appeal. The last two aren't favorite, but names I find very cute.
6/10: William, James, Charles, Matthew, Eric,
Good names, but a little plain. I like Will and Charlie, though. Except, Eric. Eric is just a name I don't have opinions on.
5/10: Daniel, Ryan
Not fond of either.
4/10: Jack
Not a fan.
3/10: Brian
Less of a fan.
Overall, I like your list of names! Most of them aren't my style, though.
My thoughts:
Girls -
9/10: Alice
Very nice! My fifth favorite girls' name at the moment. I prefer the Welsh form Alis, though
8/10: Lydia, Marie, Josephine, Caroline
Lydia and Josephine are very pretty! Not currently on my favorites list, but they'll probably get on there someday. Marie is my 14th favorite girls' name right now. I'm fond of Caroline. I think I prefer Coraline, but they're both very nice.
7/10: Julia, Anastasia, Maddalena, Fleur, Ivy
These are all either names that are very pretty but not quite my taste (first 3) or names I used to really like but have lost their appeal (last 2)
6/10: Maria, Charlotte, Clementine, Sophia, Rosalie, Laurel
These are names that aren't my taste, or I've had unfortunate associations with. Sofia would be a 7/10. Rose, my 4th favorite girls' name at the moment, would be a 9/10.
5/10: Helen, Eleni, Emma, Matilda, Isabela
I can see the appeal of these names, but they either just don't feel quite right (first two) or I don't like (last three).
4/10: Melanie, Giulia, Madeline
Names I'm not a fan of.
2/10: Eleanor.
I just can't stand Eleanor, unfortunately.
Boys -
9/10: Antonio
Somehow this name isn't in my favorite boys' fifty, but I love it.
8/10: Owen, Jonathan, Thomas
These are in my favorite boys' fiftyish. All good associations.
7/10: Joseph, Nathan, Elliot, Andrew, Theodore, George
First four were old favorites that have lost some of their appeal. The last two aren't favorite, but names I find very cute.
6/10: William, James, Charles, Matthew, Eric,
Good names, but a little plain. I like Will and Charlie, though. Except, Eric. Eric is just a name I don't have opinions on.
5/10: Daniel, Ryan
Not fond of either.
4/10: Jack
Not a fan.
3/10: Brian
Less of a fan.
Overall, I like your list of names! Most of them aren't my style, though.
This message was edited 9/22/2024, 6:59 PM
