View Message

What is the harm in Elbowin wanting to make his or her own contribution of help to the original poster? What does it matter if their contribution partially contained information that you had already provided? He or she might perhaps have thought, as a native German (assuming the information in their profile is correct), that their contribution contained some additional information that "fine-tuned" things further. I see no harm in that - it is better to have a lot of information than to have very little at all, even if that means that some bits are repeated here and there. I personally believe that it is rather stifling (perhaps even reminiscent of censorship) to try to create an atmosphere here where a user is discouraged from making a contribution when their contribution is (partially) going to contain similar information that an other user has already provided.... where a user is discouraged from expanding on information that is already provided. Keep that up and you will find that this board, which is already fairly silent to begin with (at least when compared to the other message boards on BtN), will eventually go dead. At least, I can't see how people would want to take the time and effort to help someone with their question when there is a negative atmosphere of this kind on the board... an atmosphere where you basically shouldn't touch a question when it has already been "touched" by an other user. This board shouldn't be some kind of "I was here first so go find some other thread to reply to!" kind of contest or whatever. That is not scientific (nor particularly inviting or welcoming, for that matter) and will thus hurt the scientific aims of this board.

---

With that said, it is unfortunate that Elbowin's apparent eagerness to help appears to have caused some offence on your part, but I doubt that their actions were intentional or purely aimed at offending you. For one thing, they appear to be a long-time user (according to their profile) and I doubt that long-time users (who in my experience so far always have a respectable reputation) would resort to petty things such as that.

... Load Full Message