This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

Re: Interchangeable name - Sarah / Jemima
Which census years?Are you sure that they weren't alternating between their first & middle names?
"Like arrows in the hands of a warrior are sons born in one's youth." Ps. 127:4
JoHannah Jubilee, BenJudah Gabriel, Aaron Josiah, Jordan Uriah,
Maranatha Nissiah, (Anastasia Nike, 1992-1992), Jeshua David,
Shiloh Joshana, Elijah Daniel, Hezekiah Nathaniel, Zephaniah Joseph
vote up1vote down

Replies

Don't think so. I've got a mother who is Jemima on all records except the 1861 census, when she's Sarah…..and her daughter who is Sarah Ann on most records I've found so far - except the same 1861 census, when she's Jemima. There is another child called Jemima born in 1864. Confusing!
vote up1vote down
Yes, mistakes are rampant in old census records. Names, ages, birthplaces, etc. Especially if the record is a transcript from an original record. The more transcriptions the more things get lost in translation.
vote up1vote down
Don't you think it could have been just a mistake? All kinds of errors crept into old records (and even modern ones, for that matter). I would assume that Jemima was the mother, and Sarah Ann the daughter.
vote up1vote down
Yes I do wonder if it could be a mix up. I don't know whether the 1861 enumerators took details verbally (in which case he could quite easily have mixed up the mother and daughter's names) or if the householder filled out a form like in 1911 (in which case it would have been harder to mix them up). I just wondered if Jemima and Sarah were 2 versions of the same name - sort of like Elizabeth and Betty.
vote up1vote down
Yes, it's probably just a data entry error, whether modern or original.
vote up1vote down
They are both direct Anglicizations of distinctly different Hebrew names.
vote up1vote down