View Message

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

Re: and the I can also mean
in reply to a message by Shay
Hi, Shai!
I don't think your name exists in the States (or it must be very rare) so I suppose you are Israeli.
Yes, I've wondered about "father of joy", too, but I haven't figured out, what this could actually mean. Being a father myself, I can feel with anyone talking about the joy of becoming a father. But what would be the "father of joy"?
I know about the "son of good luck" or "son of the south" (BENJAMIN), in German we talk about "the mother of all battles" (a very important or sever battle), but I'm not familiar with "the father of …" Do you have a clue?Andy ;—)P.S.: In case you are Israeli: Do you know a good Israeli name book?
vote up1vote down

Replies

Hi, Andy :-)I think "father of" usually refers to someone who was either the founder of something, or started an idea, invented something, etc.
At least we (and your right about me being Israeli) call Einstein "father of relativity", Herzl is "father of Zionism", Jesus we call "father of Christianity", etc. (and I think we're not the only ones, but maybe I'm wrong.)
But I don't see how we can apply that to "father of joy".On a differnt level, I suppose that if your child is "your joy", then it makes you "father of joy" :-) but of course such a name wouldn't describe the child himself (or herself in our case, which would make even less sense).Finally, I guess if we want to we can call someone who is simply very joyful "father of joy". Implying he looks as if he himself has invented joy, or something...Again, doesn't make much sense as a name go give to a baby girl, but not impossible to come up with reasons.P.S.
Don't know any name books, sorry...P.S. 2
Your knowledge of languages is very impressive! May I ask how many languages you speak?
vote up1vote down
Hi, Shai!
I'm afraid our discussion (and especially your last question) exeeds the purposes of this message board. Maybe we could communicate by email. So if you give me a safe email address (many people are afraid of spam) we could go on.
Andy ;—)
And what is your interest in names?
vote up1vote down