View Message

Words have meanings, names often don't. When somebody hears Tampa Sue Fobert, they usually do not think of it as a comprehensible phrase, but they could think of it as a name.

---

But what names do have is history: examples being previous people who are well known enough to be recalled by the name, happenstances of a name being popular with a particular people at a particular time, and the reasons why the name was chosen by a lot of people, or the particular people who named a particular child. When the reason for chosing the name is primarily other than being a name that was heard, i.e. when a name is being, partly at least, being created, those reasons then constitute the etymology of the name.

---

The post to which you were responding merely claimed that whatever was meant by `the meaning of the name' in the post that started the thread, whether it was true or false, is not the etymology of the name: those were not the meanings from which the name Tampa Sue Fobert was created. nt meant that the poster said everything in the subject and no text needed to follow.