View Message

The most stereotypical name for an English girl
So I was at an improvisation workshop and we were creating a story whose protagonist was supposed to have the most stereotypical name for an English girl. We’re not talking particular realism here, the character in question had been ostracized from her family because she preferred hot chocolate to tea.I suggested the name Betty, which was accepted, I’m wondering what you guys think.“Someone once said that it wasn’t so hard to do right; what was hard was to know what was right to do.” William X. Kienzle

Replies

The first name that jumped into my head was Beatrice. That may not be very accurate. I'm not sure how common it currently is in the UK. But it's an English name that I'd associate more with the UK than other English-speaking places.
I know an English Poppy who's about 8 or 10 by now. And I know two adult English sisters named Maryrose and Heather. Their parents wanted to name their first daughter Rosemary, but one of her grandmothers objected strenuously that it was too common, so they rearranged it.Betty seems very dated to me, but I don't have any data!
Honestly, to me and a few others in my region the most stereotypical British girl's name is probably Daphne, or for the younger generations, probably a toss up between Maisie and Amelia
Well, Betty's an English-language name, but it doesn't really say "England" or "British" to me at all.I'd pick something like Poppy or Jemima or Matilda.
I've never met an English Betty.The Elizabeth's I know are: Lizzie/Lizzy, Liz, Beth, Buffy, Tizzy and Ellie. I also know three full name Libbys.
Ellie and Laura are by far the most common English girls names I know. Other suggestions: Tamsin, Kate, Lucy, Chloe, Gemma
If I’m thinking of stereotypical upper-crust-y British names, I’d have to say Philippa/Pippa. (I happen to love that name lol)
I guess it would depend on the stereotype!I might say Jane. As in "See Jane Run", and Jane Doe. That would work for North America as well as the UK. Jane is pretty retro but it feels more timeless than Betty.
My mind goes straight to Anne and Rose, although those aren't stereotypically young sounding. Other ones, hmm. Isla, Imogen, Jemima, Daisy, Harriet.It looks like Betty has risen in popularity in the UK in recent years, so it's not unrealistic. It sounds older/retro to me (in contrast to comparable NNs like Ellie), but I'm American.

This message was edited 10/13/2024, 1:18 PM

Imogen 100%!
I would go with Poppy. Kind of silly, very English.
The only Poppy I know is American.
That doesn't change the fact that Poppy is much more popular in England.
Mary came to mind.Mary Poppins - quintessentially English. And the kids were Jane and Michael Banks.So, Mary or Jane, or Maryjane / Mary Jane.

This message was edited 10/13/2024, 12:56 PM

Anna, Louise and Emma come to mind.
Betty is 1950s American to me. She goes to school with Sally and Peggy-Sue.Lucy and Alice are very English to me. A more modern one would be Poppy.
I think I would've picked Jane.
Since I'm in the US, and Jane was not as popular here as there, I sort of stereotype it as British.
Also Ellie, Kate.
Depending when the story is set, I guess. Betty seems older to me, like from 100 years ago.
Kate is ubiquitous in the U.S. If you watch any American movie or TV show from about 2000-2015, commonly there will be a female protagonist named Kate.