View Message

Rank these names best to worst
Random collection of girl names from my PNL. Rank them, give me your opinions, etcSable
Fleur
Amethyst
Willow
Hedwig
Tempest

This message was edited 6/17/2024, 4:13 PM

Replies

Fleur- my favorite
Tempest- nice
Amethyst- sounds awkward for a name
Sable- shouldn't be a name
Willow- not a fan
Hedwig- not a fan
Willow-Love
Amethyst-Really like
Fleur-Super pretty
Sable-Like the sound
Tempest-Fierce, I like it
Hedwig-I can only think of the owl from Harry Potter

This message was edited 6/18/2024, 5:35 PM

Best to worstWillow
Sable
Fleur
Amethyst
Tempest - too stormy, sounds too much like temptress, temptation
Hedwig - I just can't not think of the owl
Fleur > Willow > Sable > Tempest > Amethyst > Hedwig
Fleur > Sable > Willow > Hedwig > Amethyst > Tempest.
I feel like Fleur is well developed and strong. 8/10
Sable is beautiful 8/10
Willow is fine, but it's a bit too trendy for me. I loved it when I was younger. 6/10
I don't love the pronunciation of Hedwig. It's pretty enough, though 6/10
I'm really not a fan of Amethyst. I'd prefer Ruby or Violet. It doesn't feel like a name for me. 3/10
Tempest is fine, but it reminds me of temper, and I'm not sure how I also don't think a tempest is a great thing to be named after. It's pretty otherwise, though 3 or 4/10
Call me oldfashioned, but the only ones that look like girl names to me are Fleur and Hedwig, of which I prefer Fleur. It seems to have been adopted by Anglophone parents more than Hedwig, which is fine in a German context but could be deliberately misunderstood elsewhere.
That’s so funny because I see Hedwig as a boy name.
I rather think you're alone there. Certainly not in Germany, and I doubt whether Harry Potter had a trans owl.
Ah, I've never read Harry Potter, so that must be why. Never heard of the owl.
Hedwig -captivating
Tempest -the imagery!
Fleur -it's beautiful but I just can't pronounce it right
Amethyst -intriguing but not quite sold on it
Willow -too trendy
Sable -don't see it as a name
Don't really like any
Best to worstFleur
Willow
Amethyst
Sable
Tempest
Hedwig
Willow > Amethyst > Fleur > Sable > Tempest > HedwigThe last two seem like boy names to me.
Fleur
Sable
Willow
Amethyst
Hedwig
TempestIf I was forced to use any on a real child, it would be Fleur and only as a middle name.
Hedwig > Fleur > Amethyst > Willow > Sable > Tempest
I am pretty indecisive, so it's hard to rank these, but my favourites are probably Willow and Hedwig.