New Post
Search
HelpMadison (on a boy)
Do you think it would be insane to use Madison on a boy today??
-- Sarah
-- Sarah
Archived Thread - replies disabled
1
Replies
Yes
Madison was one of those names I use to like (with Greyson and Mason), but it's 100% in the girls' camp now, and it shortens to Maddie. Madison is such a little princess name I can't imagine a boy with the name, unless it was spelled Mattison or something. There's atleast 2 Madisons (or Madysyn, etc) in a class, it would seem really unfair for a little boy to have to deal with that, plus all the harrassing an adult guy would get for having a girlie name.
Madison was one of those names I use to like (with Greyson and Mason), but it's 100% in the girls' camp now, and it shortens to Maddie. Madison is such a little princess name I can't imagine a boy with the name, unless it was spelled Mattison or something. There's atleast 2 Madisons (or Madysyn, etc) in a class, it would seem really unfair for a little boy to have to deal with that, plus all the harrassing an adult guy would get for having a girlie name.
1
1
I don't know. I certainly like it much better for a boy,
but I'm wondering how much a boy would like being named Madison.
but I'm wondering how much a boy would like being named Madison.
1
Thanks!
Yeah, I don't know. I won't actually be naming any children for a good ten years, so maybe by then the associations will have died down somewhat.
-- Sarah
Yeah, I don't know. I won't actually be naming any children for a good ten years, so maybe by then the associations will have died down somewhat.
-- Sarah
1
Maybe as a mn
Actually I think Madison sounds very much a surname, not suitable as fn for anyone.
And as it seemss that boys must be very macho in USA, it seems unwise to give a boy which is so very popular for girls.
I think a more uncommon name, like Maximilian, Malachy or Matthias, would be much better.
"But it’s all right now.
I learned my lesson well.
You see you can’t please everyone
So you got to please yourself."
Rick Nelson, GardenParty
"It does not become me to make myself smaller than I am." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
Actually I think Madison sounds very much a surname, not suitable as fn for anyone.
And as it seemss that boys must be very macho in USA, it seems unwise to give a boy which is so very popular for girls.
I think a more uncommon name, like Maximilian, Malachy or Matthias, would be much better.
"But it’s all right now.
I learned my lesson well.
You see you can’t please everyone
So you got to please yourself."
Rick Nelson, GardenParty
"It does not become me to make myself smaller than I am." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
1
Thank you!
Personally, I'm not opposed to the surnames-as-first names thing, but I know that a lot of people don't care for it.
You might be right about the macho thing, although, since I think that's a gross part of my culture, giving into feels hypocritical... But maybe it would be unfair to force my opinions on my son.
Those are nice names. Max is my brother's name, actually. :)
-- Sarah
Personally, I'm not opposed to the surnames-as-first names thing, but I know that a lot of people don't care for it.
You might be right about the macho thing, although, since I think that's a gross part of my culture, giving into feels hypocritical... But maybe it would be unfair to force my opinions on my son.
Those are nice names. Max is my brother's name, actually. :)
-- Sarah
1
1
1
I think its too girly despite the son at the end. I know (or have heard of) too many girls with this name. )
Mum to Hayley Anne
Mum to Hayley Anne
1
Thanks! I think that many would agree with you.
-- Sarah
-- Sarah
1
Wonderful for a boy
Aside from the whole meaning issue, Madison is simply too overused for girls at the moment imo. On the contrary, Madison for a boy sounds very refreshing to me.
I especially like Madison if the mother's name is Maud or Matilda.
Miranda
Proud adopter of 15 punctuation marks; see my profile for their names.
Aside from the whole meaning issue, Madison is simply too overused for girls at the moment imo. On the contrary, Madison for a boy sounds very refreshing to me.
I especially like Madison if the mother's name is Maud or Matilda.
Proud adopter of 15 punctuation marks; see my profile for their names.
1
1
The name Madison as a given name is not my style in general. However, if one were to use it as such I would much prefer it on a boy. If you like Madison for a boy and its current high popularity on girls doesn't bother you, go for it (then again I'm a strong supporter of using boy-turned-girl names on their original gender).
1
1
Boy name, for sure
I love the name Madison for a boy...that's the only way I even like it. On girls I find names ending in -son to be highly annoying not to mention completey absurd. That's just My opinion though, so no one jump down my throat.
"And I believe, that angels breathe, and hat love will live on and never leave" -Josh Groban
I love the name Madison for a boy...that's the only way I even like it. On girls I find names ending in -son to be highly annoying not to mention completey absurd. That's just My opinion though, so no one jump down my throat.
"And I believe, that angels breathe, and hat love will live on and never leave" -Josh Groban
1
Thank you! I'm on your side...
-son names on girls really get to me. I think Madison is a great boys' name, but I wouldn't want to curse my kid with a name that everyone else finds ridiculus.
-- Sarah
-son names on girls really get to me. I think Madison is a great boys' name, but I wouldn't want to curse my kid with a name that everyone else finds ridiculus.
-- Sarah
1
My friends brother's name is MAdison, and there's nothing wrong with him. By that, I mean he doesn't get picked on or anything because of his name. I think I like it more for a boy than a girl.
1
Thank you!
That's good to hear. I like it better for a boy, too. :)
-- Sarah
That's good to hear. I like it better for a boy, too. :)
-- Sarah
1
Well, although it really, really SHOULD be a boys name (sigh), I think that it is entirely too popular for girls to use on a boy. It's been taken over. I don't really care for it either way, though.
What are the convulsions of a city in comparison with the insurrections of the soul?
Man is a depth still greater than the people.
Man is a depth still greater than the people.
1
Thanks! You're probably right.
-- Sarah
-- Sarah
1
I think that in today's world a male Madison would be a target for bullying. Most people don't realize that Madison started off as a surname/ male name.
However, I do like the name on a boy. Maybe for a middle name?
"My idea of good company ... is the company of clever, well-informed people who have a great deal of conversation; that is what I call good company."
~Jane Austen
However, I do like the name on a boy. Maybe for a middle name?
~Jane Austen
1
No, I don't.
However, I'm so damned sick of the name that I don't want to hear it on anyone, whether it's a little girl, a little boy, or a goldfish.
Array
Mick Jagger is older than:
1. Velcro
2. Cake mix
3. Israel
A revolution without dancing is a revolution not worth having.
However, I'm so damned sick of the name that I don't want to hear it on anyone, whether it's a little girl, a little boy, or a goldfish.
Array
Mick Jagger is older than:
1. Velcro
2. Cake mix
3. Israel
A revolution without dancing is a revolution not worth having.
1
Ditto.
1
Ha ha, fair enough. Thanks!
-- Sarah
-- Sarah
1
Well where I live in England it wouldnt be insane , I actually know of a boy called Madison
This message was edited 6/5/2006, 2:56 PM
1
1
i only like it for a girl..
1
Thanks! That's fair.
-- Sarah
-- Sarah
1