I find many of these names beautiful and even exciting, but then again, I'm not an Italian. With those percentages, I would assume these top names would get judged as basic and boring names.
I like...
Leonardo
Francesco
Lorenzo
Alessandro
Andrea - After I watched the series "La figlia di Elisa" years ago I've found Andrea one of the sexiest men's names, lol.
Tommaso
Riccardo
Edoardo
Matteo
Antonio - My great-grandfather's middle name!
Federico
Giovanni
Pietro
Filippo
Luca - I only like Luca in the Italian context, otherwise it's a bleh trendy name to me.
Giulio
Alessio
Aurora
Giulia
Ginevra
Alice - Though I don't quite like the Italian pronunciation...
Emma - My own name :)
Giorgia
Beatrice
Greta
Vittoria
Matilde
Ludovica - I'm actually quite smitten by Ludovica!
Arianna
Gaia
Francesca
Alessia
Adele
Elisa
Viola
Formerly known as Remora L.