View Message

Aggie is kind of cute yet not too frivolous. Enough like Maggie that it could grow on me if I knew one. Though slightly ruined by my having been exposed to Texas A&M (and other ag universities) being called "Aggies."

---

Maisie is Mazey ... sticky-saccharine, sloppy farmgirl, from-a-twee-book name.

---

Frankie isn't a name I've ever seen as a woman's name until the 2000s (and even then, as a film character). If I had ever seen it IRL I might not hate it so much ... but as it is, I find it irritatingly synthetic and perkie-chirpie Hollywood, like Piper or Coco, trying to be a character. I'd use Fran for Frances / Francine instead.

This message was edited 2/2/2020, 1:15 AM

Maisie I really like a lot. Aggie and Frankie I can do without. Neither appeals to me at all. Best to worst would be Maisie, Aggie and Frankie.

Maisie first. Not bad on the whole, and May is a good nn.
Aggie: nn only; quite friendly.
Frankie: awful, whether as a nn or as a full name.

I really like Maisie. It feels very nicknamey though so I'd only use it with another fuller name to fall back on, but I'm not sure what that name would be.

---

Aggie and Frankie are also nickname names. I don't mind Aggie, but I'm not a fan of Frankie. It just reminds me of teen greaser gangs with their leather jackets and switchblades and stuff lol

1. Maisie
2. Frankie
3. Aggie

---

I like Maisie but it is probably too cutesy and childish. I dislike Frankie personally but I get the appeal of it so I've ranked it higher than Aggie which I neither like nor see the appeal of.

Assuming they're full names:

---

1. Frankie (because I love Frances and it's less dated on a girl)
2. Maisie
3. Aggie

---

But I prefer Agatha "Aggie" or Agnes "Aggie" to Maisie. I only like Maisie if her full name is Mairead and she goes by Mairead when she grows up.

This message was edited 2/1/2020, 1:03 AM

Maisie, then Frankie, then Aggie.

Maisie first, Aggie second and then Frankie

Maisie is ok, dont like the others

Don't love any really. Frankie I think is awful, I don't see the appeal at all.

---

Preference
1. Maisie
2. Aggie
3. Frankie

As nicknames only they're fine. I don't like them for formal first names.

---

Best to worst: Maisie, Frankie, Aggie.

Love em all. They're all very poodle-skirt.

---

Frankie is the best, then Maisie, then Aggie.

Hi !!!!

---

1 Maisie because it reminds me amazing and it's youthful and cheerful

---

2 Aggie because it reminds me Agatha and it's similar to Iggy that I like for a boy.

---

3 Frankie nothing special.

They're bad.

---

Ranking:

---

1. Maisie
2. Frankie
3. Aggie

---

But they're all awful.

I like Agnes and Frances, but not Aggie and Frankie. Maisie is ok but quite popular here.

I like them. Frankie has a 1920s feel to it, sister to Maxine. Aggie is familiar, and Maisie reminds me of the children's books and the fictional detective Maisie Dobbs.

---

Frankie, Aggie, Maisie

I don't like any of them. They all sound childish and unpleasant to me. Frankie > Maisie > Aggie.