View Message

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

Re: Lily
in reply to a message by -=A=-
I've seen people from teenage moms to late life moms use this name.
I'm not picking, but just trying to understand.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Well to me it's a mixture of poor taste, and a want for your child to always sound like a child without considering her place in the adult world.
vote up1
I disagreeI actually think that Lily can go both ways, and I can see it on women from a tiny child to a woman in her 90's. I think it's sweet, but "sweet" does not mean "unrefined." It's attractive and I know very few Lilys.
vote up1
and I can see it on women from a tiny child to a woman in her 90's.Maybe in the backwoods of West Virginia.
vote up1
Hey, watch it.I'm from West Virginia, buster. We're not all rednecks and hillbilles. They're more toward Southwestern WV. (*cough*Calhoun County*cough*)I've only met two Lilys, FYI. One is 9 and one is 60. I don't like it as a full name, but I think Lilith and Lillian are nice, if not names I would use.ETA: I read your other post. Elizabeth nn Lily is nice as well. :)

This message was edited 3/16/2008, 1:19 PM

vote up1
LOL. Sorry. I am native Marylander. It's just an expression we use. Meant no offence.
vote up1
Yeah, I know. [m]I was born in Maryland and we moved to WV (Eastern Panhandle) when I was four. I live in the more civilized area of the state. The Southwestern part is like a whole different world; it's amazing. They use swinging bridges and they have more unpaved roads than any other place I've seen. It takes forty minutes to get to a store from some places!
vote up1
I wouldn't know what goes on there, I've never been. But I live in Los Angeles and I can definitely see it.
vote up1
Well, I'm from South Dakota and I've known several people named Lily...although one (who was 100 years old thank you) went by Lilly (with 2 L's).
vote up1
So you would prefer Lillian, Lilith or a "fuller" sounding name where Lily would just become the NN?
As a more mature naming choice?

This message was edited 3/16/2008, 8:35 AM

vote up1
Well, I'd prefer Elizabeth nn Lily. I don't think Lillian or Lilith are often shortened.
vote up1
Fair enough, thanks for clarifying your logic.
vote up1