View Message

I think it's okay. An honoring surname in the middle doesn't bother me on either gender. Carlisle is more surnamey to me rather than strongly masculine or feminine, but, in any event, I don't believe a masculine mn on a girl has much of an impact on whether or not that name will ever be used on boys again.

---

I don't like Carlisle at all, but I like Carlie, Carlise, Carlisa, and Carlyn even less.