New Post
Search
HelpYates
I think this name (for a male) has risen out of GP status into PNL status for me (but I can't add it because it's not listed--unless someone knows how to override it). Opinions? I promise, you can't possibly hurt my feelings. :)
This message was edited 3/12/2008, 8:33 PM
Archived Thread - replies disabled
1
Replies
Yeats
As in, William Butler.
That's what I'd think of anyway.
Besides thinking it's surnamey-trendy. So many surname-trend names seem lame to me - ones with -ton, -son, -er, and ending in -s particularly - like they're trying to make the person seem like someone s/he's not, or trying to create an aura of "uppaclass" or "romantic oldtime manners" or "one of the good ol' boys" or somesuch. I can appreciate names with romantic, heroic, or theatrical associations, but surnames seem to do it so artificially.
Anyway, Yeats, a poet-name, okay - I think it's lame, but it's not unacceptable.
As in, William Butler.
That's what I'd think of anyway.
Besides thinking it's surnamey-trendy. So many surname-trend names seem lame to me - ones with -ton, -son, -er, and ending in -s particularly - like they're trying to make the person seem like someone s/he's not, or trying to create an aura of "uppaclass" or "romantic oldtime manners" or "one of the good ol' boys" or somesuch. I can appreciate names with romantic, heroic, or theatrical associations, but surnames seem to do it so artificially.
Anyway, Yeats, a poet-name, okay - I think it's lame, but it's not unacceptable.
1
I kept thinking of Yeats too
I'm glad I'm not the only one, heh.
I'm glad I'm not the only one, heh.
1
I did think of Yeats, but it doesn't please me like Yates does for some reason. It's really straddling that fine line between GP and "would use" for me now.
1
Andrea Yates, sorry
Aside from her, I also think that Yates is too surnamey and trendy-sounding. It'd sound nice as a middle name if it were a family surname though.
Aside from her, I also think that Yates is too surnamey and trendy-sounding. It'd sound nice as a middle name if it were a family surname though.
1
I would say "no way" because of Andrea Yates, assuming you know who that is because you live in the U.S. Even if I didn't associate it with her, I still would say "no" because it's surnamey and trendy.
This message was edited 3/12/2008, 8:36 PM
1
I don't know who Andrea Yates is. I guess I'll look it up. Doubt it will be too strong of a BA to deter my admiration of Yates though.
1
She was the woman who drowned her five children several years ago. Very sad story.
Here's the Wikipedia link
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Yates
Here's the Wikipedia link
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Yates
This message was edited 3/12/2008, 8:43 PM
1
:(
I remember now.
I remember now.
1