View Message

I like Harper and love Edie. I'm not a fan of Edith, so Eden is a lovely alternative.

I don't like them together, although Eden is probably in my top 2 EVER girl names. The spelling for the nn does not make any sense to me at all. It looks like EYE-dee because of the "y".

---

I personally like E alone as a nn, and I'm not much of a single initial liker. Maybe occasionally Ed, either as "Ed" or as "EED".

I like both names, but I'm not sure about Eydie as a nickname for Eden. I guess it would be better than "Harpy" as a nickname for Harper, though. :-) I also think the names would be very nice as a sibset.

I think Harper and Eden would make a great sister set. As far as Eydie, well Edie would be better.

I love Harper on a girl. I like Eden too and Edie (spelled with-out the unnecessary 'y').

I only like Eden for a boy. Harper I don't mind for either gender. Though both names seem to be becoming rather popular. I dislike the nn Eydie in any spelling.

I love Harper and Eden for boys (if used as first names). Eden I like as a girl's MN, Harper I don't like on a girl.

I like Eden, which is odd because I'm not super-religious, and the nickname, too. Harper is nice but gaining in popularity a little too fast, I think.

I am not a huge fan of Eden, though I like the NN Edie. I'd leave out the unnecessary Y, though. Harper is cute.