View Message

Thanks everyone for the responses. I'm still totally confused and can't decide which of the two I like better. I had never thought of Magnolia and Scarlett sounding like a romance novel together etc. so I'll have to consider that- I like how they sound southern but I don't want too names that are just too much together so we will have to see. I do love Beatrix as well so I might be leaning towards that for now-
Thanks so much for everyones help:)

I personally prefer Beatrix.

---

But I think that Magnolia will go better with Scarlett.
And Magnolia is a beautiful name.

I like Scarlett and Beatrix. Beatrix Pearl is my fave combo.

Magnolia Ruth

Scarlett and Magnolia *definitely* belong together

---

Magnolia Ruth is very pretty. I was going to vote for Magnolia before I even read the text of your message, but then I find out the choice is for a sister to Scarlett?! Oh, fer shur it's Magnolia.

---

[Said Scarlett's mom...]

I prefer Magnolia, but Beatrix is beautiful, too. All the combos you mentioned are gorgeous and would make a fine sister to Scarlett.

I prefer Magnolia. Magnolia Ruth is a lovely combo. Beatrix is nms.

I prefer Beatrix -- and love all three of the combos you have for it.

---

Both names are equally fine with Scarlett, imo.

Beatrix Pearl.

Beatrix Pearl. Though Beatrix Maude is nice too. I think Beatrix goes better with Scarlett.

I really like the quirkiness of Magnolia. Beatrix has never appealed to me, but I think that's because I associate the name with a woman I once knew who we all called Trixie. I remember thinking how odd that was when I met her.

I happily voted for Beatrix Maude on your poll. :-)

---

Any of the Beatrix combinations could have gmv. It was difficult. But I didn't even come close to voting for Magnolia. Now that I know her sister is Scarlett I'm even happier I didn't vote for it. Scarlett and Magnolia make you seem like romance novel junkies. Too cutesy by far.

---

Beatrix Maude is nostalgic and flows beautifully. Love it.

Mm, I like both of them a lot. Usually, Magnolia would win. However, I would find Magnolia and Scarlett just a little bit themey, so I am going to have to go with Beatrix. Beatrix Pearl and Beatrix Maude are quite nice, but I hate Willow. When I say it aloud it sounds like I can't pronounce Willa. I am pretty choosey about nature names, as well. Other mn suggestions:

---

Beatrix Clare
Beatrix Louise
Beatrix Nora
Beatrix Jemima
Beatrix Eliza
Beatrix Eleanor
Beatrix Adelita
Beatrix Adele
Beatrix Ada
Beatrix Inés
Beatrix Matilda
Beatrix Minerva
Beatrix Lily
Beatrix Anne
Beatrix Alice
Beatrix Caroline
Beatrix Isobel
Beatrix Sylvie

I prefer Beatrix and I think it sounds better with Scarlett. I like the combo Beatrix Willow the best.

I like Scarlett and Magnolia Pearl