View Message

[Opinions] Rank these names best to worst
Random collection of girl names from my PNL. Rank them, give me your opinions, etcSable
Fleur
Amethyst
Willow
Hedwig
Tempest

This message was edited 6/17/2024, 4:13 PM

Replies

Fleur- my favorite
Tempest- nice
Amethyst- sounds awkward for a name
Sable- shouldn't be a name
Willow- not a fan
Hedwig- not a fan
Willow-Love
Amethyst-Really like
Fleur-Super pretty
Sable-Like the sound
Tempest-Fierce, I like it
Hedwig-I can only think of the owl from Harry Potter

This message was edited 6/18/2024, 5:35 PM

Best to worstWillow
Sable
Fleur
Amethyst
Tempest - too stormy, sounds too much like temptress, temptation
Hedwig - I just can't not think of the owl
Fleur > Willow > Sable > Tempest > Amethyst > Hedwig
Fleur > Sable > Willow > Hedwig > Amethyst > Tempest.
I feel like Fleur is well developed and strong. 8/10
Sable is beautiful 8/10
Willow is fine, but it's a bit too trendy for me. I loved it when I was younger. 6/10
I don't love the pronunciation of Hedwig. It's pretty enough, though 6/10
I'm really not a fan of Amethyst. I'd prefer Ruby or Violet. It doesn't feel like a name for me. 3/10
Tempest is fine, but it reminds me of temper, and I'm not sure how I also don't think a tempest is a great thing to be named after. It's pretty otherwise, though 3 or 4/10
Call me oldfashioned, but the only ones that look like girl names to me are Fleur and Hedwig, of which I prefer Fleur. It seems to have been adopted by Anglophone parents more than Hedwig, which is fine in a German context but could be deliberately misunderstood elsewhere.
That’s so funny because I see Hedwig as a boy name.
I rather think you're alone there. Certainly not in Germany, and I doubt whether Harry Potter had a trans owl.
Ah, I've never read Harry Potter, so that must be why. Never heard of the owl.
Hedwig -captivating
Tempest -the imagery!
Fleur -it's beautiful but I just can't pronounce it right
Amethyst -intriguing but not quite sold on it
Willow -too trendy
Sable -don't see it as a name
Don't really like any
Best to worstFleur
Willow
Amethyst
Sable
Tempest
Hedwig
Willow > Amethyst > Fleur > Sable > Tempest > HedwigThe last two seem like boy names to me.
Fleur
Sable
Willow
Amethyst
Hedwig
TempestIf I was forced to use any on a real child, it would be Fleur and only as a middle name.
Hedwig > Fleur > Amethyst > Willow > Sable > Tempest
I am pretty indecisive, so it's hard to rank these, but my favourites are probably Willow and Hedwig.