View Message

I had a similar question recently, except it was for a book character. I picked Scarlett because it suited her personality more. For a baby, this isn’t an option. With you and your wife’s names, I feel like Scarlett fits a bit better, but Charlotte would also work. Even if a Scarlett doesn’t know another Scarlett, she will certainly know Charlottes. For a real baby, I would pick Charlotte. If you plan on more kids, think about what style you like. I like Helen and James, and Scarlett would feel like an odd one out. Go with what you like best, and ignore popularity.